We use third party cookies to personalize content, ads and analyze site traffic.

Blog

Typing vs. Handwriting : Pros and Cons

There are strong arguments for both teaching typing and handwriting in schools. Here's a breakdown of the pros and cons:
Typing Pros:
It allows writers to stay with straight neck and head if they memorise the keyboard
Efficiency: Typing is much faster than handwriting, allowing students to capture more information during lectures or discussions.
Memory and typing: Mastering touch typing is beneficial for memory. Memorising the location of the keys stimulates brain activity and can improve cognitive function.
Attention and typing: When typing, once touch typing is mastered, attention can be fully focused on the content.
Neatness: Typed work is generally neater and easier to read, especially for students with poor handwriting.
Editing: Editing and revising work is much easier with a computer, which can save students time and improve the quality of their writing.
Accessibility: Typing can be easier for students with physical limitations that make handwriting difficult.
Preparation for the future: In today's digital world, strong typing skills are essential for most careers and academic pursuits.
Reduced paper consumption: Typing eliminates the need for paper, which can save trees and reduce deforestation
Digital storage: Digital documents can be stored electronically, eliminating the need for physical storage and its associated environmental impact.
Cons:
Cognitive benefits: Some research suggests that handwriting may have cognitive benefits for learning and memory, though this is still debated.
Distraction: Computers can be a source of distraction, leading students to multitask or go off on tangents.
Digital divide: Not all students have access to computers or reliable internet at home, which could create an uneven playing field.
Computer production requires significant resources for mining materials like metals and rare earth elements.Data on precise quantities is difficult to obtain.
Electronic waste: Manufacturing and disposing of computers and electronic devices contributes to e-waste, a growing environmental concern.
Energy consumption: Computers and related devices use energy, which can contribute to greenhouse gas emissions if generated from fossil fuels. Energy consumption during manufacturing is also significant.
Handwriting Pros:
Cognitive benefits: Studies suggest handwriting may improve cognitive development, memory, and fine motor skills.
Focus: The physical act of handwriting may help students focus on the information being presented.
Retention: Taking notes by hand may lead to better information retention compared to typing.
Organisation: Handwritten notes can be a good way to develop organisational skills.
Reusability: Paper can be recycled, while electronic devices often cannot.
Durability: Physical documents can last for a very long time, while digital documents can be corrupted or lost.
Cons:
Slowness: Handwriting can be slow, making it difficult to capture all the information in a fast-paced class.
Divided attention: When writing by hand, you need to concentrate on both the content and the movements of your hand.
Neatness: Students with poor handwriting may struggle to produce clear and legible work.
Editing: Editing and revising notes can be time-consuming and messy with handwritten work.
Accessibility: Handwriting can be difficult for students with physical limitations.
Paper production impact: Paper production uses resources like water and energy, and can contribute to pollution.Manufacturing pens, pencils, and notebooks has an environmental footprint.
Overall:
From a purely environmental standpoint, typing has a slight edge due to the potential for significantly reduced paper use. However, the environmental impact of electronics and energy consumption shouldn't be ignored.